Sunday, February 26, 2017

Is It The End Of An Era? The Rundown On #Boycottpinupgirlclothing

Boycottpinupgirlclothing
Photo soruce: Change.org
Yes, I know I'm late on this but I wanna do this article for pin-up girls such as myself who aren't in the know. So I was scrolling through Instagram and I saw a post with the hashtag #Boycottpinupgirlclothing so of course, I clicked on it to see what it was about. Then did a little research.Basically, a brand called "Pinup girl clothing" launched a collection called "Chinese New Year" some people found it offensive and culturally appropriating, resulting in the hashtag #Boycottpinupgirlclothing


I'll show some of the posts here:

First of all, let me just say, I love this picture. It was an empowering moment for me and I will always cherish it. What I am not down with, is a certain CEO (I'm looking at you, Laura) trying to use said picture as a smoke screen or at the very least as a joke or jab given the events of the last few weeks. This picture was taken in February of 2016 and posted in March of 2016, and she actually went back recently and added these hashtags #boycottpug #boycottpinupgirlclothing on the repost she had on her page. What was her intention? Who knows. Was she trying to deflect, taunt, make fun... I'm not sure why anybody would go back to an old post and add hashtags that had nothing to do with the photo at the time of taking it. I am not your negro, I am not your token. Please don't use me to "prove you're not racist". I will not help you in that way. You have others that are happy to oblige in that area. I am not the one.
A post shared by torchestogether_ (@torchestogether_) on

Here are some tweets of the founder of PUG talking to a #boycottPUG supporter:


Boycottpinupgirlclothing


Boycottpinupgirlclothing


Boycottpinupgirlclothing

Boycottpinupgirlclothing


"Today, Laura started tagging pictures of her POC friends with w/ #Boycottpinupgirlclothing, to gaslight and derail Using POC as props Tsk Tsk. -shelovesdresses"

Here's a photo of the dresses from the collection:


boycottpinupupgirlclothing
Photo sorce: thedayilydot

Do to pin-ups in the past being predominantly white, I think now more than ever we need models of every race to encourage women of all races to start dressing vintage. Representation matters. I’m not saying that people of other races can’t wear something that’s in Asian culture, I’m just saying they could have used more Asian models. I mean, There are tons of Asian pin-ups in the community why not get them to model for you? Although I don't think we should boycott them, I don't think they tried to offend anyone and I don't think they were trying to be racist.


What do you dolls think? do you think that the collection was in bad taste? or do you think people are just making a big deal out of nothing?

6 comments:

  1. Cultural appropriation is a touchy subject, however the error made I didn't think were as "cultural appropriation" as they were insensitive and uneducated. So, yes, I think people are over reacting a bit. Asian prints have been used time and time again, and were made to be sold to both Asian and tourists (aka white people) alike, much like Hawaiian prints. So, it's not to much the print, as it is the uneducated choice to say "Chinese New Year" as it is really "Lunar New Year". However, no ethnic holiday should really be used to sell a product. That is a little cultural appropriation-y. Another uneducated choice were the colors they chose for the print. It's my understanding that the colors mean bad luck and death. So, no "real Asian" is going to want to wear this. Then they did not use an Asian model for the initial shoot, so it was rather white-washed.

    To me it's much less of a big deal as it is the Native American aspects, with headdresses and such, or the geisha thing. Using sacred items (like headdresses) out of their original purpose or images that have negative histories (like geishas) are much more harmful.

    That's my two-cents!

    xoxo
    -Janey

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I feel like they could have used more Asian models.
      Representation matters, and since pin-up were mostly White back in the the day, it's important that we now show all races in pin-up/vintage fashion. So women of every color can look at a model and relate to her and see herself wearing the clothes that the said model is wearing.

      Delete
  2. Hm, thanks for the post! I don't think this is really bad taste ...
    xx from Bavaria/Germany, Rena
    www.dressedwithsoul.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for your comment! love your blog by the way!

      Delete
  3. Why not boycott them for providing subpar service and excruciating, arrogant sneers in all of their photos?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, I'm not sure about their service because I have yet to order from them.
      And as for their photos I suppose you're talking about the ones on their Instagram?
      I don't find the remarks arrogant, but maybe you can link to some examples?

      Delete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Disclaimer

This blog contains Ads and sponsored content to help keep this blog running and to bring you the best content possible.